I found this photograph in my Facebook timeline shared by some of my friends in the wake of recent beheading of Indian soldiers at LOC. I was surprised to say the least and concerned enough to drag myself to write a blog. Let's start with a little brainstorming. Do you like what you see in the picture? Does it make you laugh in a sarcastic way? Or does it sadden you?
Let us assume Kushal shared this picture (I don't want to mistakenly target anyone). When Kushal shares this picture one could assume that he likes the sarcasm in it, and may be even thinks India is not aggressive enough and should learn something from USA and Israel. Now, this is disturbing. Does Kushal really expect India to declare war on Pakistan or just wants India to have a tougher stance about the whole issue? While the former would be disastrous to say the least, the latter can be done along multiple dimensions and, severing of sporting ties is one of them. Let us go through them one by one.
We all know both India and Pakistan are nuclear powers. We also know that our neighbour on the north-west front is not particularly a thoughtful one, at least statistically speaking. Declaring war on a country is not a matter of impulse and requires cognizance of the global political canvass. Beheading of soldiers and mutilating their bodies is an act of cruelty and in violation of military code of conduct. Our soldier, and for that matter any soldier, doesn't deserve this. However, can we expect India to attack Pakistan on this pretext when Pakistan hasn't even publicly accepted it? We, as citizens of India, should think about it without being emotional.
The next point is the comparison to USA and Israel. India is not poised in the global stage (political and financial) as USA is. Other nations will not "bow" to India's decision to attack Pakistan and, let's face it that no matter how much we kid ourselves that it is a bilateral issue, it is not. If USA is so hell-bent on eliminating terror from the face of the world why doesn't it force Pakistan to take concrete actions against terrorist groups or wanted terrorists? For example, Hafiz Saeed is one of the most-wanted terrorists by USA apart from other countries including India and it is widely known that he is in Pakistan. What stops USA to force Pakistan to hand him over? So, let us not bring USA into the equation at all because we can go on citing examples about USA's double standards. Now, let us talk a little about Israel. Israel clearly enjoys the support of USA and receives military aid and assistance among other things. Given this support, would you see Israel's actions against Palestine as audacious? Well yes, but it is as audacious as bullying the angry urchin on the road when the big brother is smiling at you in agreement. And again, we can go on talking about this at length but what USA or Israel do is not the point here. The point is whether India or India's situation can not be compared to these countries. I think it can not be. Think about it.
Finally, "we will not play cricket with you" sounds like a joke in the context of this picture. Well, this is debatable too. History reveals that sporting and cultural sanctions are political in nature and is a strong assertion against a nation. When India says that it will not engage in any sporting or cultural ties, please don't ridicule it. It is not a small or insignificant sanction. Had it been ineffectual, resuming cricket between the two nations would not be seen as a diplomatic move. So, that's food for thought.
So, what is the point of this long rant? The point is we as the youth of India should not be ignorant of the complexities our nation is faced with. We should not look at a country like USA or UK or China and hang our head in dismay with a feeling of "They can do it but we can't." There is no doubt that our governments (present and past) have been found wanting in many areas including the handling of ties with Pakistan and that is a completely different topic for debate. However, trivializing issues and ridiculing our nation's policy in a global public forum is not justified. Instead we can try to fully understand the problems and engage in constructive criticism rather than frivolity like this picture.
As a final note, I would like to leave you with this short editorial.